All comparisons

RefRef vs Smile.io

Loyalty for stores, SaaS, and apps, without order-count pricing.

Smile.io is a polished loyalty app for Shopify and BigCommerce stores, and RefRef runs loyalty, referrals, and affiliates on one open-source platform. Smile.io prices by monthly orders, adds $20 per extra 100 on Growth, and lists no affiliate program; RefRef prices by active participants with no overage and pays affiliates through PayPal.

Open sourceFree up to 1,000 active participantsNo share of your revenue

Updated October 20, 2026, checked against the official pages of Smile.io.

Feature scorecard

RefRef

12/12

Smile.io

2/12

+4 partly

  • YesOpen sourceSmile.io: Proprietary; its terms bar attempts to discover the source code.
  • YesNo vendor lock-inSmile.io: Full data exports on paid plans; API only on Plus ($999/month) and up.
  • YesPricing that doesn't tax your growthSmile.io: Priced by monthly orders; Growth adds $20 per extra 100 orders.
  • YesReferral, affiliate, and loyaltySmile.io: Points, VIP tiers, and referrals; no affiliate program listed.
See all 12 rows
01RefRef vs Smile.ioFeature by feature

RefRef vs Smile.io: feature comparison

RefRef and Smile.io, feature by feature
FeatureRefRefSmile.io
Open sourceYesAGPLv3 on GitHub. Use RefRef Cloud or run it yourself.NoProprietary; its terms bar attempts to discover the source code.
No vendor lock-inYesFull data export, REST API, and webhooks.PartlyFull data exports on paid plans; API only on Plus ($999/month) and up.
Pricing that doesn't tax your growthYesPriced by active participants. No share of referred revenue, no fee on your own payout rail.NoPriced by monthly orders; Growth adds $20 per extra 100 orders.
Referral, affiliate, and loyaltyYesAll three program types on one integration.PartlyPoints, VIP tiers, and referrals; no affiliate program listed.
AI assistant and MCPYesSet up and run programs from the in-app assistant, Claude, Cursor, or Codex.Not listedNot listed on its pricing page.
Cash payouts with tax formsYesPayPal payouts in 98 countries. W-9 and W-8BEN collected.NoRewards are discounts, free products, and gift cards; no cash payouts.
Rewards inside your billingYesAccount credit, discounts, and plan upgrades in Stripe, Paddle, Polar, Dodo Payments, and RevenueCat.PartlyStore discounts, gift cards, and subscription rewards; no SaaS billing listed.
Shopify and WooCommerceYesNative Shopify app and WooCommerce plugin.PartlyShopify and BigCommerce; WooCommerce not listed.
Signup attribution for your auth stackYesBetter Auth plugin and recipes for Clerk, Supabase, Auth0, WorkOS, and Auth.js.NoRuns on Shopify and BigCommerce store accounts; no auth integrations.
Embeddable widget and join pagesYesBranded referral widget and public partner join pages.YesBranded loyalty launcher and page; embeds vary by plan.
Custom link domainsYesShare links on your own domain.Not listedNot listed on its pricing page.
Free planYesFree up to 1,000 active participants.YesFree up to 200 monthly orders, with points and referrals.

Smile.io facts checked on October 20, 2026 against its official pages. See sources

Switch from Smile.io to an open-source platform, free to start.

Start free
02Why teams switchThe case

Why teams choose RefRef over Smile.io

01

Affiliates with cash payouts, next to points

Smile covers points, VIP tiers, and customer referrals. RefRef adds affiliate programs with cash payouts, so loyalty members, referrers, and partners share one integration and one dashboard.

02

Pricing that ignores your order count

Smile plans are capped by monthly orders, and Growth adds $20 for each extra 100 orders. RefRef prices by active participants with no overage, so a busy season is not a bigger bill.

03

Built for SaaS and apps as well as stores

RefRef runs on Shopify and WooCommerce, and rewards inside Stripe, Paddle, Polar, Dodo Payments, and RevenueCat with account credit, discounts, and plan upgrades. It is open source, and you can run it from Claude or Cursor through MCP.

03Inside RefRefProduct tour

Everything you need, from the first click to the payout.

RefRef Console home: referred signups, purchases, and attributed revenue

Referral, affiliate, and loyalty in one place

Run customer referrals, a partner program, and a loyalty program side by side, each with its own rewards and results.

RefRef Console: referral, affiliate, and loyalty programs

Rewards inside your billing

Give account credit, discounts, or plan upgrades straight in Stripe, Paddle, Polar, Dodo Payments, or RevenueCat.

RefRef Console: choosing how rewards are delivered in Stripe

Partners, invitations, and applications

Invite partners, approve applications, and give each one a branded join page and link.

RefRef Console: partners, invitations, and applications

Cash payouts, done for you

RefRef pays partners through PayPal in 98 countries, collects W-9 and W-8BEN forms, and shows every statement.

RefRef Console: payout statements and transfers
04PricingWhat you pay

Smile.io pricing vs RefRef pricing

RefRef

RefRef plans
PlanPriceIncludes
Free$0Up to 1,000 active participants
Starter$49/month5,000 active participants ($29 billed annually)
ProFrom $119/month10,000 to 50,000 active participants, custom domains

No overage, no share of referred revenue. Managed PayPal payouts cost 2%.

Smile.io

Smile.io plans
PlanPriceIncludes
Free$0200 monthly orders, points and referrals
Essential$15/month500 monthly orders, loyalty page, 1 integration
Standard$79/month1,000 monthly orders, bonus events, 2 integrations
Growth$199/month2,500 monthly orders, VIP tiers, points expiry, $20 per extra 100 orders
Plus$999/month, billed annually7,500 monthly orders, API access, $5 per extra 100 orders
EnterpriseCustom, annual billingUnlimited orders, data warehouse sync
05IntegrationsEcosystem

Plugs into the stack you already run.

Native billing, commerce, and auth integrations, plus an open API, webhooks, and MCP for AI agents. The ecosystem grows every month.

Billing
StripePaddlePolarDodo PaymentsRevenueCat
Commerce
ShopifyWooCommerce
Auth
Better AuthClerkSupabaseAuth0WorkOSAuth.js
Payouts
PayPalW-9 and W-8BEN forms
Automation and AI
REST APIWebhooksMCPZapierMakeActivepiecesClaudeCursorCodex
06SwitchThree steps

Switch from Smile.io in three steps.

Your partners and customers keep what they earned. We help you move.

1

Export customers with their points balances, VIP tiers, and referral history from Smile. Full data exports are on its paid plans.

2

Import members into a RefRef loyalty program with the same balances and tiers, matched to the same customer accounts by your store or app customer ID.

3

Recreate earning rules and rewards, add your referral program, then test an order, a redemption, and a refund before you switch the widget.

07QuestionsFAQ
01

How much does Smile.io cost?

Smile.io is free up to 200 monthly orders, then $15/month for 500, $79 for 1,000, and $199 for 2,500 on Growth, plus $20 per extra 100 orders; Plus is $999/month billed annually. RefRef prices by active participants instead: free up to 1,000, then $49/month for 5,000, with no overage.
02

Does Smile.io have an affiliate program?

Smile.io lists points, VIP tiers, and referrals, but no affiliate program, and its rewards are discounts, free products, and gift cards rather than cash. RefRef adds affiliate programs with managed PayPal payouts in 98 countries.
03

Does Smile.io support WooCommerce?

Smile.io lists Shopify and BigCommerce, not WooCommerce. RefRef has a native WooCommerce plugin and Shopify app, and works for SaaS and apps through Stripe, Paddle, Polar, Dodo Payments, and RevenueCat.
04

Does Smile.io have an API?

Only on Plus ($999/month, billed annually) and up; full data exports are on paid plans. RefRef offers a REST API, webhooks, and full data export, and its code is AGPLv3.
05

Can I move my Smile.io points balances to RefRef?

Yes. Export members with their points balances and VIP tiers, import them into a RefRef loyalty program keyed by the same customer IDs, and keep unused discount codes valid in your store.

When Smile.io fits

Choose Smile.io if you run a Shopify or BigCommerce store, want a proven plug-in loyalty program with thousands of merchant reviews, and do not need affiliates, cash payouts, or rewards outside your store.

Sources, checked October 20, 2026

Written by the RefRef team. Smile.io is a trademark of its owner; RefRef is not affiliated with it. Plans change, so check the official pages before you buy. Spot an error? Tell us and we correct it.